Dolby 3D
Glasses-free 3D TVs are still not good enough

15 Jan 2014 | Rasmus Larsen |

3D TVs were hard to find at CES 2014, but certain TV makers continue to showcase glasses-free 3D concepts. We saw the latest development in glasses-free 3D at CES, including Dolby 3D and Ultra-D. Glasses-free 3D technology is getting better, but it is still not there yet.

CES 2014: The state of glasses-free 3D

If you visited Sharp’s booth at CES you would see a gigantic 85-inch TV with 8K resolution – 16 times Full HD. If you moved a bit to the right, around a corner, you would see the same TV with glasses-free 3D technology, developed in collaboration with Philips and Dolby (Dolby 3D). You would think that a screen of this magnitude would look impressive, but it did not.

Dolby 3D
Sharp, Philips and Dolby’s 3D technology is nowhere near impressive


Sharp’s non-3D version of the 8K panel is wildly impressive, but the glasses-free 3D version is fuzzy, has narrow viewing angles, and lacks depth. It is not truly bad, at least not if you manage to find the sweet spot (the two white lines at the bottom have to line up), but it is certainly not great either. TV makers have said that higher resolutions will make glasses-free 3D possible, but since this is an 8K panel we simply think Sharp, Philips, and Dolby need to fundamentally change their 3D technology. This one is clearly not working.

To find the best glasses-free 3D technology at CES we actually had to head over to a relatively unknown player in the field; StreamTV Networks, who has developed Ultra-D. We have heard about the technology before, but this was the first time we saw it in action ourselves. We saw a demo of a PS3 game, movies and a news studio. The last one was most convincing, but also the one with least action in it. The game – Assassin’s Creed (not the new one) – was not too impressive, and it was clear that the resolution of the game was simply too low for 3D.

Ultra D – glasses-free 3D
StreamTV has the best glasses-free 3D technology right now, but it is not yet ready for primetime


We see potential in Ultra D, but high-resolution content is required if TV makers want their 3D TVs to shine. However, while we were more convinced by Ultra D than Sharp, Philips, and Dolby’s 3D technology we cannot say that we agree with the high praise we had heard. It is simply not good enough yet, and certainly not something we would want in our living room.

Samsung tried to wow spectators with a “glassless” 3D Ultra HD TV showing the Grand Canyon 3D Blu-ray, but the experience was bad, actually dizzying. We saw a few other glasses-free 3D concepts, too, but nothing that managed to break out of the what-is-this-crap club.



Share on:


Latest news

UEFA.tv

UEFA debuts free streaming service UEFA.tv

14 Jun 2019 | Rasmus Larsen |
Sony A9G OLED

Sony A9G OLED wins 'King of TV' at 2019 TV Shootout

13 Jun 2019 | Rasmus Larsen |
The Wall Luxury

Samsung will launch 'The Wall Luxury' microLED displays in July

13 Jun 2019 | Rasmus Larsen |
Xbox

Next-gen Xbox console will have a disc drive

12 Jun 2019 | Rasmus Larsen |
Sony A8G

Sony 2019 A9G and A8G OLED TVs now available

11 Jun 2019 | Rasmus Larsen |
Iron Man

All Marvel Cinematic Universe films will be remastered in 4K

10 Jun 2019 | Rasmus Larsen |
Project Scarlett

Next-gen Xbox: 8K graphics, 120fps, SSD & ray-tracing - launching in 2020

10 Jun 2019 | Rasmus Larsen |
Batman

WarnerMedia streaming service likely to be more expensive than Netflix, Disney+

07 Jun 2019 | Rasmus Larsen |