Your browser is not Javascript enable or you have turn it off. We recommend you to activate for better security reasonSony A9F OLED crowned 'King of TV' at 2018 TV Shootout - FlatpanelsHD

Sony A9F OLED crowned 'King of TV' at 2018 TV Shootout

25 Sep 2018 | Rasmus Larsen |

Sony ended LG’s four-year run and saw its new A9F flagship OLED TV crowned ‘King of TV’ at the 2018 TV shootout. Sony A9F and LG E8 tied for ‘Best HDR TV’.

2018 King of TV

After being hosted at the CE Week last year, the 2018 TV Shootout returned to Scarsdale, NY, and Value Electronics where it all started. Four TVs from LG, Samsung, and Sony were competing – two OLED TVs and two LCD TVs.

The four TVs were:
  • 65” LG E8 OLED ($)
  • 75” Samsung Q9FN LCD ($)
  • 65” Sony A9F OLED ($)
  • 75” Sony Z9F LCD ($)

    A panel of expert judges and attendees were asked to vote in three distinct categories. All of the TVs were calibrated, with a Sony’s BMV-X300 reference monitor used as the reference for all TVs to be judged against.


    2018 TV Shootout


    The overall winner of the 2018 ‘King of TV’ category was the Sony A9F OLED (AF9), which scored marginally higher overall than the LG E8 OLED, based on the expert judges’ votes. The Sony Z9F LCD came in third while Samsung Q9FN finishing in last place.

    The team of expert judges was asked to find the ‘Best Living Room TV’ (SDR day mode), ‘Best Home Theater TV’ (SDR Reference Mode), and ‘Best HDR TV’ (HDR Reference Mode). Sony A9F took home the wins in both of the former categories, while LG E8 and Sony A9F were tied in the HDR category.

    Also read: List: Best TVs (review scores)


    2018 TV Shootout


    Sony is clearly the big winner at this year’s event. Besides the A9F OLED being the overall winner, Sony’s flagship LCD model beat Samsung’s flagship LCD model. However, some attendees have pointed out that Z9F suffered from blooming and raised blacks. The results of the attendees’ votes will be announced later.

    Here are all of the results (expert judges).

    King of TV 2018 (expert judges)

    ModelGrand total
    LG OLED65E8P845
    Sony XBR-65A9F850
    Sony XBR-65Z9F832
    Samsung QN65Q9FN715

    Best Living Room TV (expert judges)

    Model Motion handling Off-axis performance Upscaling Peak brightness Total
    LG OLED65E8P58.0072.0061.0059.00250.00
    Sony XBR-65A9F64.0070.0061.0059.00254.00
    Sony XBR-65Z9F56.0055.0060.0072.00243.00
    Samsung QN65Q9FN51.0040.0063.0072.00226.00

    Best Home Theater TV (expert judges)

    Model Black level / perceived contrast Shadow detail Skin accuracy / skin tones Near black uniformity Total
    LG OLED65E8P76.0068.0066.0052.00262.00
    Sony XBR-65A9F71.0066.0070.0056.00263.00
    Sony XBR-65Z9F57.0070.0064.0067.00258.00
    Samsung QN65Q9FN49.0029.0055.0052.00185.00

    Best HDR TV (expert judges)

    Model Color accuracy / skin tones 4000 nit tone-mapping Wide color gamut High brightness HDR (high ABL)Perceived sharpness (UHD detail) Total
    LG OLED65E8P66.0066.0069.0060.0072.00333.00
    Sony XBR-65A9F70.0059.0065.0066.0073.00333.00
    Sony XBR-65Z9F65.0058.0067.0072.0069.00331.00
    Samsung QN65Q9FN56.0064.0059.0062.0063.00304.00
    - Source: Value Electronics



  • Latest news

    LG 77-inch OLED TV

    LG Display to ramp up 77" OLED mass production next year

    19 Aug 2019 | Rasmus Larsen |
    IFA 2019

    Roku CEO to give keynote at IFA 2019 - expansion in Europe?

    16 Aug 2019 | Rasmus Larsen |
    Samsung Q90R

    Samsung reportedly shifting production of LCD TVs to OLED TVs

    16 Aug 2019 | Rasmus Larsen |
    Plex new desktop app

    Plex is phasing out Home Theater PC (HTPC) support

    16 Aug 2019 | Rasmus Larsen |
    TCL 8-series miniLED 4K LCD TVs

    TCL unveils 8-series miniLED 4K LCD TVs, improved 6 & 5-series TVs

    15 Aug 2019 | Rasmus Larsen |
    Philips OLED984 TV

    New Philips flagship OLED984 with B&W soundbar, Dolby Vision & Atmos

    15 Aug 2019 | Rasmus Larsen |
    EISA Awards 2019-2020

    Winners: EISA Awards 2019-2020

    15 Aug 2019 | Rasmus Larsen |
    Marvel UHD Blu-ray discs

    Disney releasing six Marvel titles on UHD Blu-ray today

    13 Aug 2019 | Rasmus Larsen |